The Hudson River Derby, contested between New York City FC (NYCFC) and the New York Red Bulls (NYRB), is one of Major League Soccer’s most fiercely contested rivalries. While relatively new, the derby has quickly grown into a significant fixture on the MLS calendar, marked by passion, intense matches, and a clear geographical divide.
One of the key elements fueling the rivalry is the differing identities and origins of the two clubs. The Red Bulls, originally the MetroStars, were a founding member of MLS and have a history dating back to 1996. For much of that time, they were the only MLS team in the New York metropolitan area. They’ve cultivated a loyal fanbase, particularly in New Jersey, where they play their home games at Red Bull Arena in Harrison. The Red Bulls are perceived by some as the establishment team, with a longer history and a dedicated, if somewhat less glamorous, following.
NYCFC, on the other hand, arrived on the scene in 2015, backed by the deep pockets of City Football Group (owners of Manchester City). Their ambition was clear: to establish a strong presence *within* New York City. Playing initially at Yankee Stadium, they sought to capture the hearts of a broader New York audience, appealing to those who might have been hesitant to support a team located outside the city limits. NYCFC’s arrival challenged the Red Bulls’ dominance and introduced a new level of competition and spending power to the New York soccer landscape.
The on-field battles have been consistently entertaining, often high-scoring, and punctuated by moments of drama and controversy. The derby matches are characterized by a noticeable increase in intensity and physicality compared to other MLS games. Both teams have enjoyed periods of dominance in the rivalry, but neither has established a sustained period of supremacy. This back-and-forth dynamic adds to the rivalry’s appeal and unpredictability.
Beyond the pitch, the fanbases contribute significantly to the derby’s atmosphere. Supporters’ groups for both teams are known for their passionate displays of support, creating a vibrant and often boisterous environment at matches. The rivalry extends into social media, with fans engaging in playful banter and fierce debate leading up to and following each game. The geographical aspect of the rivalry is also crucial. While both teams represent the New York metropolitan area, NYCFC’s focus on the city itself has created a clear “city versus suburbs” dynamic that adds another layer of complexity to the rivalry.
In recent years, the stakes of the Hudson River Derby have increased, with both teams regularly competing for playoff spots and aiming to challenge for the MLS Cup. NYCFC’s MLS Cup victory in 2021 further intensified the rivalry, as it gave their fans bragging rights and cemented their status as a legitimate force in MLS. As both clubs continue to develop and evolve, the Hudson River Derby is poised to remain a captivating and compelling fixture in American soccer for years to come, a testament to the power of local rivalry and the growing passion for the beautiful game in New York.
3600×2396 york city fc bronx ny from www.iloveny.com 
2771×1847 mls york red bulls york city fc soccertoday from www.soccertoday.com 
2000×1333 york city fcs inaugural mls squad from mlsmultiplex.com 
1589×1046 york city fc player salaries denver post from www.denverpost.com 
1200×668 york city fc numbers mls ambition rankings sports from www.si.com